Friday, 24 May 2024

Animal Crossing: City Folk Review

I have been a long-time fan of the Animal Crossing franchise, giving high praise to the original GameCube version. However, the Wii edition, City Folk, leaves me feeling a bit underwhelmed. In this review, I will explore the reasons behind my mixed feelings and provide an in-depth analysis of the game.

A Familiar Yet Uninspiring Experience

City Folk is an extension of the 2005 DS release, Animal Crossing: Wild World, rather than a direct sequel to the GameCube original. While it retains the charming “rolling barrel” perspective, it feels more suited for the DS than the Wii. On the positive side, the game allows data transfer from the DS version, providing a head start in your new virtual life. You start by naming your town and character, then diving into part-time jobs at Nook’s Cranny and eventually decorating your home.

A Realistic Virtual Town Experience

Animal Crossing: City Folk immerses you in a virtual town where you spend most of your time exploring. Interacting with your quirky neighbors is a major part of the game and is where it truly shines. Nintendo’s trademark humor is evident in every line of dialogue, making for laugh-out-loud moments. The city is a new addition, offering various activities like shopping, bidding on items, and even getting a haircut. Your house can be customized with an impressive array of furniture and decorations. Fishing, bug catching, and tree planting add to the overall experience.

The Lack of Purpose

While some players appreciate the open-ended nature of City Folk, I found myself yearning for more purpose. The game mostly revolves around completing favor requests for friends or collecting items to sell and pay off your mortgage. In comparison to newer titles like Fable II or Grand Theft Auto IV, the gameplay feels shallow. The lack of substantial goals or a sense of progression can be a letdown for those seeking a more immersive gaming experience.

A Nostalgic Trip with Limitations

Animal Crossing: City Folk retains its charm and offers engaging moments, but it fails to keep up with the advancements in the gaming industry. The game’s interactions with the world seem limited, especially when compared to more modern titles. Additionally, the absence of the NES games collection, which was a highlight in the original, is a disappointment. Nintendo now encourages players to purchase these games separately from the Virtual Console.


Animal Crossing: City Folk is a delightful but slightly outdated experience. While it provides a realistic virtual town setting and humorous interactions, the lack of purpose and limited gameplay mechanics may leave some players wanting more. However, for fans of the franchise and those seeking a relaxed gaming experience, City Folk still has its merits.


  1. Are there any major differences between City Folk and the previous Animal Crossing games?
    City Folk is an extension of the DS release, Animal Crossing: Wild World. It offers new features like the city location and online interactions but lacks significant innovations compared to the original GameCube version.

  2. Can you play Animal Crossing: City Folk without previous experience with the franchise?
    Yes, City Folk can be enjoyed by newcomers to the series. The gameplay mechanics are straightforward, and the game provides a charming introduction to the animal-filled world of Animal Crossing.

  3. How does Animal Crossing: City Folk compare to other life simulation games?
    Animal Crossing: City Folk offers a relaxed and casual gaming experience, focusing on daily interactions and personal customization. It may not have the depth or complexity of some other life simulation games but still holds its own unique charm.

  4. Is Animal Crossing: City Folk worth buying?
    If you are a fan of the Animal Crossing franchise or enjoy laid-back, open-ended gameplay, City Folk is worth considering. However, if you prefer more structured objectives and a greater sense of progression, you may find it lacking in appeal.